Stuck at Home with Heavy Tanks? Why Medicare Denies 'Portable Oxygen Concentrators' (POC) and How to Win the Appeal

Stuck at Home with Heavy Tanks?

You have COPD or severe asthma. Your doctor prescribes oxygen. You imagine receiving a sleek, lightweight machine that you can carry in a shoulder bag, allowing you to go to the grocery store or visit grandkids.

Instead, the medical supply company drops off massive, heavy steel tanks and a trolley that weighs 20 pounds. You are effectively under house arrest. When you ask for the lightweight "Portable Oxygen Concentrator" (POC) you saw on TV, they say: "Sorry, Medicare doesn't cover that."

This is misleading. Medicare does cover POCs. But the system is rigged to discourage you from getting one. Today, we explain why suppliers hide these devices and exactly what your doctor needs to write to force their hand.

---

The "Rental Cap" Economics (Why They Hide the POCs)

To understand the denial, you must follow the money. Medicare does not "buy" you an oxygen machine. They rent it for you.

💰 The Supplier's Secret Math

Medicare pays the Durable Medical Equipment (DME) supplier a fixed monthly fee (bundled payment) for your oxygen equipment—regardless of whether they give you a cheap tank or a high-tech POC.

• Compressed Gas Tank Cost: ~$50 (Cheap)
• Portable Oxygen Concentrator Cost: ~$2,500 (Expensive)

If the supplier gives you a POC, their profit evaporates. If they give you a tank, they make money. That is why they tell you "POCs aren't covered." They are protecting their margins, not your health.

The Loophole: "Standard" vs. "Portable"

Medicare rules state that the supplier must provide equipment that meets your medical needs. If standard tanks prevent you from leaving your home, they are failing to meet that need.

However, simply saying "I want to travel" isn't enough. Medicare considers travel a luxury, not a necessity.

The Winning Strategy: The "ADL" Argument

To get a POC approved, you must prove that the heavy tanks prevent you from performing Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) inside or near your home.

The Magic Words for Your Doctor

The old "Certificate of Medical Necessity (CMN)" was eliminated. In 2026, you need your doctor to include specific language in your Standard Written Order (SWO) and Clinical Notes:

"The patient lacks the physical strength/stamina to pull a liquid or compressed gas cart (E0424). The weight of the standard equipment restricts the patient to bed/chair confinement, preventing them from ambulating within their residence for toileting, feeding, and basic hygiene. Therefore, a Portable Oxygen Concentrator (E1390/E1392) is medically necessary to maintain mobility and prevent muscle atrophy."

Key Takeaway: Do not focus on "going to the mall." Focus on "I cannot walk to my own mailbox or kitchen because the tank is too heavy."

The 5-Year Rule Trap

There is one massive catch. Medicare pays for oxygen equipment for a 36-month (3-year) rental period. After 36 months, the supplier stops getting paid, but they must continue to service the equipment for 2 more years (Total 5 years).

If you are in Year 4 of your contract, the supplier will absolutely refuse to give you a new POC because they are getting paid $0 per month. You are usually stuck until the 5-year cycle ends.

The Fix: If your health has changed significantly (e.g., your flow rate requirement dropped or increased), your doctor can prescribe a "New Medical Necessity." This might restart the 5-year clock and allow you to switch suppliers to one who offers POCs.

Action Plan: Fight for Your Freedom

1. Check Your Flow Rate: POCs are pulse-dose (they puff air when you inhale). If you need high-flow continuous oxygen (e.g., 4 Liters/min), a POC literally cannot handle it. Make sure you are a candidate first.
2. Shop Around: Do not just accept the first DME supplier Medicare suggests. Call them and ask: "Do you provide the Inogen One or Philips Respironics POCs to Medicare patients?" If they hesitate, hang up and call the next one.
3. File a Complaint: If a supplier refuses to upgrade you despite a valid Standard Written Order (SWO), call 1-800-MEDICARE. Suppliers hate official complaints because it risks their contract.

(Disclaimer: Medicare guidelines for oxygen (NCD 240.2) are complex. This article explains general coverage rules as of 2026. Copays and deductibles apply. Always consult your pulmonologist.)

Demand Mobility

Oxygen keeps you alive, but mobility makes life worth living. Don't let a greedy supplier anchor you to your couch. Demand the technology you deserve.